The Whynter ICM-15LS [Amazon] is a compressor fashion ice cream maker that’s been extremely rated in different critiques and is a fairly priced in comparison with different home machines.
So in my quest for the right ice cream maker, I assumed I ought to test it out!
However earlier than we begin, I ought to simply make clear one level. The Whynter ICM-15LS is one other of these ice cream makers in what I name the “third tier” of home compressor machines.
All of the ice cream makers on this group are manufactured by one firm in China referred to as Foshan Nordika, to be white labeled by numerous manufacturers world wide.
So for instance, in Europe the Whynter ICM-15LS is offered by Unold. And within the US many different Foshan Nordika ice cream makers are offered by numerous totally different manufacturers (not simply Whynter).
Now there’s nothing mistaken with this. Foshan Nordika know what they’re doing and make good ice cream makers. However it’s value noting, as a result of if you’re attempting to decide between two totally different machines, each is likely to be made by the identical producer and there may really be little or no distinction between them.
For extra info on the varied totally different ice cream maker which might be made by Foshan Nordika, try my full information to purchasing an ice cream maker.
Issues I like and Issues I don’t
Anyway, on this assessment I’ll rapidly clarify how the Whynter ICM-15LS works. I’ll have a look at the construct high quality, the usability and the standard of the ice cream it makes. And at last I’ll recommend a few alternate options in case this isn’t the proper machine for you!
How doe the Whynter ICM-15LS work?
The Whynter ICM-15LS is a compressor ice cream maker. What does this imply? Effectively, there are three forms of ice cream maker and what makes every one totally different is the best way they freeze the combination:
- with ice and salt
- with detachable bowl that you simply pre-chill within the freezer
- with a inbuilt freezer (or compressor)
So the Whynter ICM-15LS has it’s personal inbuilt freezer that it makes use of to freeze the ice cream. These compressor ice cream makers are probably the most handy you should buy…
There’s no messy ice and salt. There’s no bowl taking on area in your freezer. There’s no pre-planning in any respect. Whenever you need ice cream you simply activate the machine to pre-cool, throw within the combination and in 30 minutes or so that you’ve acquired ice cream!
However, compressor machines are massive, heavy, considerably delicate and fairly costly. Should you’re unsure but whether or not a compressor ice cream maker is the proper selection for you, try my full information to picking the most effective ice cream maker.
What’s the construct high quality like?
There are 6 separate elements to the Whynter ICM-15LS, which is greater than you get with most ice cream makers:
- the primary physique which accommodates the motor, the compressor and the contols
- the bowl during which the ice cream is churned
- the paddle (or dasher) which mixes the ice cream
- a clear plastic lid
- a spatula for scraping the ice cream out of the bowl
- a measuring cup
The physique of the Whynter ICM-15LS is without doubt one of the lightest and most compact compressor ice cream makers that I’ve examined. In reality, it’s the identical dimension and weight because the Knox Gear, which is one other Foshan Nordika machine.
So it measures 15.25″ huge, 11″ deep and 9.5″ excessive (together with the lid) (28 x 24 cm x 13.5 cm). And it weighs about 27 lbs (12 kg).
The highest and sides of the casing are chrome steel, whereas the back and front are black plastic. The edges are embossed with ornamental arrows that give it away as a Foshan Nordika machine.
The back and front panels include in depth air vents. These are essential for cooling the machine whereas it’s churning and shouldn’t be obstructed. So I’d advocate leaving 4″ (10 cm) of area between the again panel and any wall.
However the energy cable is a beneficiant 60″ (152 cm) lengthy so it shouldn’t be too exhausting to search out someplace for it to sit down comfortably in your kitchen.
On the highest of the physique, to the left hand aspect, is a chamber with a metallic rod protruding from the center. The chamber is cooled by the compressor and can in flip freeze the ice cream combination. And the rod is rotated by the motor and can in flip spin the paddle that mixes the ice cream combination.
To the proper of this chamber is the management panel. It’s extraordinarily fundamental. In reality there’s simply three buttons:
There’s a few lights above the buttons, one which signifies when the machine is cooling and one which signifies when the machine is mixing.
And to the left is a really fundamental LCD show that reveals the time remaining on the churning cycle.
As I say it is a very fundamental management panel. The buttons are similar to those on the Cuisinart ICE-100, and never be sincere, identical to these buttons, they really feel a bit low-cost and nasty!
The detachable bowl
The ice cream is churned in a detachable, anodized aluminium bowl. There’s a hole tube down the center, via which the drive shaft slots, when the bowl’s positioned within the cooling chamber. And a skinny wire deal with that will help you pull it out of the chamber when the ice cream’s completed.
It has a 1.5 quart (1.Four liter) capability, which is fairly customary. Nonetheless like the opposite Foshan Nordika machine I’ve examined, it is a notably small 1.5 quart bowl! So it is advisable to be notably cautious you don’t add an excessive amount of combination, or when it expands it might overflow.
Why is the bowl detachable? Effectively, to make cleansing the machine simpler, I assume. In idea it’s far more handy to clean the bowl within the sink than to clean the bowl within the machine!
Nonetheless, this additionally provides an additional layer of insulation between the compressor and the combination, which suggests it received’t freeze fairly as quick and the ice cream received’t be fairly as easy. The dearer machines sacrifice the simple washing up for smoother ice cream by disposing of the detachable bowl!
The dasher is simply one other title for the paddle that churns the ice cream combination. All of the Foshan Nordika paddles are made from plastic and have roughly the identical design.
Nonetheless the dasher has two actually essential jobs:
- scraping frozen combination from the perimeters of the bowl and shifting it to center
- including air to the combination
These jobs are actually essential as a result of they’ve vital affect on the standard and the feel of the ultimate ice cream.
The dasher’s impression on the standard of the ice cream
Good high quality ice cream means easy ice cream. Ice cream is easy when the ice crystals are small. And the quicker we freeze the combination, the smaller the ice crystals.
What’s this acquired to do with the paddle? Effectively, on all home ice cream makers there’s a small hole between the blades of the dasher and the perimeters of the bowl. Which means that there’s at all times a layer of frozen combination left on the perimeters of the bowl that the blades can’t scrape off.
This layer of frozen combination insulates the remainder of the combination from the cooling energy of the compressor. The larger the hole between the blades and the bowl, the thicker that layer of frozen combination. And the thicker that layer, the slower the combination freezes.
The hole within the Whynter ICM-15LS is fairly small, round 1 mm, which suggests the layer of insulating ice is thinner, so the combination ought to freeze quicker and the ultimate ice cream needs to be smoother!
The dashers impression on the feel of the ice cream
How a lot air the dasher provides to the ice cream has a major impact on it’s texture. Ice lotions with numerous air are softer, lighter and fluffier. Ice lotions with much less air are denser, heavier and creamier.
The quantity of air that’s added by the dasher will rely upon the design of the dasher and how briskly it rotates. The quicker it rotates, the extra air is added.
The dasher on the Whynter ICM-15LS rotates at 56 rpm which is fairly quick for a home ice cream maker. However we’ll see how a lot air it really whips into the ice cream within the whats the ice cream like part.
The lid that comes with the Whynter ICM-15LS is strictly the identical because the lid that comes with the Knox Gear.
It’s comprised of clear plastic, with a tiny hatch that enables us so as to add mix-ins with out eradicating the lid.
Nonetheless this hatch is so small, it’s virtually definitely simpler to only take away the lid if you wish to add stuff! Not like the Cuisinart ICE-100 although, the lid is simple to lock on and off.
You additionally get a spatula and a measuring cup with the Whynter ICM-15LS. The spatula is simply the proper dimension for scraping ice cream out of the bowl when it’s prepared.
And the cup has ounces, cups and milliliter measurements on the aspect, so it’s actually helpful for measuring out the elements in numerous recipes.
Utilizing the Whynter ICM-15LS to make ice cream
There are 5 steps to creating ice cream with the Whynter ICM-15LS, identical to there are with most ice cream makers!
- make the combination
- pre-cool the machine
- churn and freeze the combination within the Whynter ICM-15LS
- switch the combination to the freezer to harden
- clear the Whynter ICM-15LS
Step 1: Make the combination
In case your recipe requires you to warmth the combination, then you definately’ll want to do that step effectively upfront to present it sufficient time to fully quiet down earlier than you add it to the machine.
But when your recipe doesn’t should be heated, then so long as all of the elements are already chilled, you’ll be able to add the combination to the ice cream maker as quickly as you’ve made it!
What’s essential right here is that you simply use a great recipe. Probably the greatest issues about having your individual ice cream maker is which you could invent your individual recipes. However they should be correctly balanced or they simply wont work. You’ll be able to’t simply throw any mixture of milk, cream and sugar into the machine and count on to get good outcomes.
So till you’ve discovered the right way to steadiness by studying about ice cream science and utilizing an ice cream calculator, I’d advocate you utilize tried and examined recipes from good blogs or recipe books.
The Whynter ICM-15LS handbook has a number of recipes. However higher nonetheless, there are the loads of implausible recipe books to attempt. Just lately Iv’e been utilizing Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream and Good day, My Title Is Ice Cream, with nice success.
An important factor to recollect is that the Whynter ICM-15LS has a comparatively small 1.5 quart (1.Four liter) bowl, so that you shouldn’t add greater than 1 quart of combination or it might overflow.
Additionally, keep in mind to comply with the recipes to the letter and ensure your ice cream combination and the Whynter ICM-15LS are completely pre-cooled earlier than you one to the opposite…
Step 2: Pre-cool the Whynter ICM-15LS
You don’t should pre-cool your ice cream maker, however I extremely advocate that you simply do. As a result of should you add a relaxing combination to a pre-cooled machine, it is going to freeze a lot quicker and also you’ll get smoother ice cream.
There’s no automated pre-cool operate on the Whynter ICM-15LS. So that you simply want to show it on 15 minutes early. The paddle will begin to flip within the empty bowl, however that’s no drawback. If you wish to you’ll be able to pre-cool with the paddle eliminated after which slip it over the drive shaft simply earlier than you add the combination.
It’s actually essential that you simply don’t let the timer attain zero throughout pre-cool. Should you do, the compressor will flip off and even should you begin the machine up once more instantly, although the paddle will start to show, the compressor received’t come on once more for an additional 2 minutes. Throughout that point, the bowl will heat up, undoing all of the pre-cooling you’ve completed!
So slightly than set the timer for 15 minutes to time the pre-cooling, I’d advocate you permit it 60 minutes after which simply add the combination when it will get to 45 minutes. This could depart loads of time to complete the ice cream. However should you do want extra you’ll be able to add time whereas the compressor is operating.
The LCD show will flick between the time left and the present temperature of the bowl each couple of seconds which is de facto helpful for maintaining observe of what’s occurring. On my Whynter ICM-15LS, the temperature tens to be round -15°F (-26°C) after 15 minutes pre-cooling, which is kind of respectable.
Step 3: Churn and freeze the combination within the Whynter ICM-15LS
As soon as your combination is chilled to fridge temperature and your ice cream maker has been pre-cooling for 15 minutes, it’s time to start out making ice cream!
Simply because it’s tremendous essential that the timer by no means reaches zero throughout pre-cooling, it ought to by no means attain zero whereas churning the ice cream both. If it does, the compressor will flip off, and received’t come on once more for an additional 2 minutes even should you begin the machine once more instantly. Throughout this time a great deal of ice cream will soften and when it re-freezes, the ultimate ice cream shall be coarser.
So, earlier than you add the combination, be sure you have a minimum of 45 minutes on the timer. And at all times regulate the machine. If the timer is getting low and it appears just like the ice cream nonetheless has a strategy to go, add extra time whereas the machine is operating.
When you’ve checked that there’s sufficient time left on the timer, that the temperature is round -15°F (-26°C) and that the paddle is rotating within the bowl, merely pour within the combination. And wait!
One issues value mentioning is that ice cream makers might be fairly loud! Compressor machines are typically slightly quieter than freezer bowl machines. However the Foshan Nordika fashions do appear to be a bit louder than machines just like the Breville and the Cusinart. The Whynter ICM-15LS varies between 77 and 79 Db, so yeah it’s loud. However not more than a hairdryer. And it’s definitely not insufferable.
How lengthy it takes earlier than your ice cream is prepared will rely upon a load of things together with the recipe, the temperature of the combination when in went within the machine and the temperature of the machine itself. It may well range wildly, so that you’ll must regulate the consistency…
Home ice cream makers received’t make ice cream to the identical exhausting consistency that you simply get from the shop. They’re simply not highly effective sufficient. What we’re on the lookout for is a consistency like comfortable serve ice cream or whipped cream. When it get’s like this, its prepared to return out. You might additionally measure the temperature. When it reaches 21°F (-6°C), it’s just about completed.
With my check batches utilizing my no-cook base, the Whynter ICM-15LS had the ice cream prepared in 30 minutes…
Should you do let the timer attain zero, the machine will robotically flip off. The compressor will cease cooling and the paddle will cease turning. Nonetheless the Whynter ICM-15LS does have a really fundamental keep-cool operate, whereby after 10 minutes the compressor will begin up once more (with out the paddle turning) and funky the ice cream for an additional 10 minutes. It would activate and off in 10 minute cycles for as much as an hour.
I don’t advocate you utilize this characteristic although as there shall be big quantity of melting in 10 minutes and when the ice cream is refrozen within the following 10 minutes, the ice crystals will solely improve in dimension resulting in a lot coarser last ice cream.
Step 4: Switch the ice cream from the Whynter ICM-15LS to the freezer
When you’re blissful the ice cream is prepared, it’s time to switch it to the freezer to harden. Now you don’t have to do that. You might simply eat it straight from the machine. And it’ll style nice.
However the issues is, it’s nonetheless solely partially frozen. So it is going to be very comfortable and it’ll soften extremely rapidly. Should you can management your self, it is going to actually profit from two or three hours within the freezer.
On this time, the remainder of the water will freeze to ice, hardening the ice cream in order that it produces a lot firmer and longer lasting scoops.
The factor you need keep away from throughout this step is extreme melting. Any ice cream that melts now will re-freeze later within the freezer. However slightly than kind new ice crystals, it is going to be part of and develop current crystals to make the ice cream much less easy.
So, get the ice cream out of the machine, right into a container and in wack it at the back of the freezer as quick as doable!
You wish to use a container that encourages quick freezing. Shallow vessels comprised of glass or metallic will expose a larger floor space to the freezing temperatures and transmit these temperatures quicker.
Pre-cool the containers in your freezer so that they’re already actually chilly if you add the ice cream. Then, as soon as the ice cream’s in add a layer of cling movie to discourage ice crystals forming on the floor, pop on the lid, and place the container at the back of the fridge the place it’s often the coldest.
It would often take between 2 and Four hours to agency up. Nonetheless tempting it’s, don’t verify too usually, as each time you open the freezer door you enable heat air during which encourages a melting/re-freezing cycle that can trigger the ice crystals to develop and the ice cream to turn out to be coarser.
Step 5: Clear the Whynter ICM-15LS
So your ice lotions within the freezer hardening. Now it’s time for the actually enjoyable half: cleansing the machine! Fortunately, cleansing the Whynter ICM-15LS is very easy.
Because the bowl is detachable you’ll be able to merely switch it to the sink the place a fast wash with heat soapy water could have it clear and glossy very quickly in any respect.
One of many good issues about compressor machines is that the bowl warms up actually quick, so any ice cream left on the aspect rapidly melts away and it’s simple to scrub. With the freezer bowl machines, as a result of the bowls keep chilly for ages, the ice cream stays frozen to the perimeters and have to attend loads longer earlier than you’ll be able to clear them.
The lid and the paddle can be rapidly washed in heat soapy water. And the the casing an cooling chamber may have a fast wipe down if there’s been any spillages. And also you’re completed. All clear in lower than 5 minutes.
How good is the ice cream from the Whynter ICM-15LS?
Effectively, the ice cream from the Whynter ICM-15LS is fairly good. As is the gelato, sorbet and frozen yogurt!
As at all times, the standard of the ice cream is all to do with how lengthy the machine takes to freeze the combination. And the Whynter ICM-15LS often freezes it sufficient to take away from the machine after about 30 minutes.
Throughout pre-cooling the Whynter ICM-15LS is ready to scale back the temperature of the bowl to round -15°F (-26°C). After which as soon as the combination is added the temperature rises and stays round 3°F (-16°C) all through the churning.
That is really neither as environment friendly because the Good Scoop nor the opposite Foshan Nordika ice cream maker than I’ve examined, the Knox Gear. Each of those machines had been capable of cool the bowl additional after which keep barely decrease temperatures all through the churning.
Whereas the Good Scoop throws away this benefit by implementing a poor paddle design, the Knox Gear makes use of an virtually similar paddle to the Whynter ICM-15LS and it rotates at roughly the identical velocity, so it’s capable of flip these constantly decrease temperatures into barely smoother ice cream.
That’s to not say the Whynter ICM-15LS doesn’t make easy ice cream. It’s smoother than the Good Scoop and is kind of the identical smoothness because the Cuisinart ICE-100. It’s simply not fairly as easy because the Knox Gear.
The Whynter ICM-15LS tends so as to add barely extra air to the ice cream than different machines with an overrun of 47% in my check batches. Solely the Good Scoop and the KitchenAid add extra air and this ends in a light-weight and fluffy ice cream.
The Whynter ICM-15LS is a good compressor ice cream maker. However it received’t be the proper selection for everybody. That will help you resolve, right here’s Three issues I like and three issues I’m not so eager on.
Three issues I like concerning the Whynter ICM-15LS
1. It’s small
Together with the Knox Gear, the Whynter ICM-15LS is without doubt one of the most compact compressor ice cream makers at present obtainable. So should you’ve acquired your coronary heart set on on ice cream maker with a inbuilt freezer however you don’t have a lot room, this may very well be a good selection.
2. It’s quick
The Whynter ICM-15LS seems ice cream in 30 minutes or much less. That’s fairly quick for a compressor machine. And it means you need to wait much less time earlier than you’ll be consuming nice ice cream.
3. It’s acquired an incredible dasher
The dashers within the Foshan Nordika ice cream makers work rather well. They scrape the frozen combination from the perimeters of the bowl actually effectively. And so they proceed to completely combine the ice cream even it hardens. So that they’re a lot better than each the Good Scoop and Cuisinart dashers!
Three issues I don’t like concerning the Whynter ICM-15LS
1. It’s a bit ugly!
The Whynter ICM-15LS has acquired to be the least engaging of all of the compressor ice cream makers I’ve examined. From a budget trying management panel to the ugly, black plastic aspect panels there’s nothing premium trying about this ice cream maker!
2. The controls are very fundamental
The management panel solely has three buttons. They’re not very tactile. And you’ll solely regulate the timer in a single path, in 10 minute intervals. You get used to this beautiful rapidly. And to be sincere you don’t want to make use of the controls loads. However they may very well be a lot better.
3. It’s not that low-cost
The Whynter ICM-15LS will not be a premium equipment from a effectively established and revered model. However it’s priced [Amazon] on the identical stage as the opposite ice cream makers that are. And because it doesn’t make ice cream that’s any higher than these different machines I don’t really feel it’s nice worth for cash.
Options to the Whynter ICM-15LS
If the Whynter ICM-15LS isn’t fairly best for you then don’t fear, as a result of there are many alternate options. And I like to recommend two of them for you beneath…
Searching for one thing cheaper (and higher)
The Knox Gear is made by Foshan Nordika, identical to the Whynter ICM-15LS. However I believe the Knox Gear is the higher ice cream maker.
Why? Effectively, I believe the total chrome steel casing is extra engaging than the two tone metal and plastic affair that covers the Whynter ICM-15LS. The management panel has correct, tactile buttons that mean you can regulate the time in each instructions. The hole between the blades of the dasher and the perimeters of the bowl is simply barely smaller. And the compressor is ready to get the bowl a great few levels colder.
And all this implies it appears higher, it’s simpler to make use of and it really makes barely smoother ice cream!
What’s extra the Knox Gear is considerably cheaper [Amazon] than the Whynter ICM-15LS!
It’s value noting once more that each the Knox Gear and the Whynter ICM-15LS are made by Foshan Nordika. You’ll be able to see the unbranded Knox Gear right here, and the unbranded Whynter ICM-15LS right here.
There’s two issues that strike me if we glance rigorously at these pages.
The primary is that the fee worth of the models is nearly similar with the Knox Gear simply barely dearer (at $97) than the Whynter ICM-15LS at ($96). How is Knox Gear capable of promote this unit so cheaply and nonetheless flip a revenue?!
The second factor is that for the reason that technical specs of the 2 machines are similar, why is it that the Knox Gear compressor performs barely higher? Is it simply pot luck? This makes me query the standard management of Foshan Nordika barely.
However the info are that in my expertise the Knox Gear machine appears higher, is less complicated to make use of and performs higher than the Whynter ICM-15LS. And contemplating it’s additionally less expensive, it’s simple to choose between the 2!
Searching for a extra established model?
Should you’re barely involved concerning the high quality of a Foshan Nordika ice cream maker otherwise you merely wish to purchase from a extra effectively established model than Whynter, then how concerning the Cuisinart ICE-100?
The Cuisinart ICE-100 really has loads in frequent with the Whynter ICM-15LS. It has a equally crappy, lo-fi and tough to make use of management panel. And it makes equally (good) high quality ice cream.
Nonetheless, the ICE-100 is considerably heavier than the Whynter ICM-15LS, suggesting higher construct high quality and parts. And to my eye the sloping design and sculpted aspect vents make it a way more engaging equipment.
Extra importantly Cuisinart is a effectively established model with lengthy standing experience in manufacturing ice cream makers. And we get a pleasant Three 12 months guarantee (5 years within the UK!) with Cuisinart home equipment!
Now I don’t assume the ICE-100 makes higher ice cream than the Whynter ICM-15LS. The Whynter ICM-15LS usually provides various air to the combination (47%). And whereas the ICE-100 comes with two dashers permitting you to range the overrun, each add much less air than the Whynter ICM-15LS (36 and 19%).
So should you like lighter, fluffier ice lotions think about the Whynter ICM-15LS. And should you like denser, thicker ice lotions think about the ICE-100. However each could have roughly the identical diploma of smoothness.
The Cuisinart ICE-100 is kind of the identical worth [Amazon] because the Whynter ICM-15LS, so I’d say it comes right down to what sort of ice cream you favor and your confidence within the Whynter model and the Foshan Nordika manufacturing high quality.
The Whynter ICM-15LS [Amazon] has a whole lot of constructive on-line critiques. And it’s a good ice cream maker.
Nonetheless, the truth is: it’s simply one other Foshan Nordika manufactured ice cream maker. And all of the Foshan Nordika ice cream makers appear to have the identical technical specs and construct high quality.
That is mirrored in the fee costs from Foshan Nordika: all of them price roughly the identical, various between $94 and $120. And the worth variations appear to have extra to do with the variations within the management panels than the rest.
So, making an allowance for that there are different Foshan Nordika ice cream makers just like the Knox Gear, which might be often considerably cheaper [Amazon] than the Whynter ICM-15LS and in my checks a minimum of, carried out higher than the Whynter ICM-15LS, it’s tough to advocate the Whynter ICM-15LS with out reservation.
For positive, it makes good ice cream. And I believe the Whynter ICM-15LS dasher performs higher than each the Breville Good Scoop and the Cuisinart ICE-100.
However except you particularly choose the excessive ranges of overrun you get from the Whynter ICM-15LS, I’d advocate that you simply go for a less expensive Foshan Nordika machine just like the Knox Gear [Amazon].
Issues I like and Issues I don’t