It constantly boils down to Rey and also Kylo.Photo: Disney

The most awful feature of Celebrity Wars: The Surge of Skywalker not being widely cherished is it makes individuals ask “What if?” Suppose various other choices had been made? Could the film have been enhanced? These sort of concerns really feel all-natural with this film specifically due to the fact that Colin Trevorrow, the initial supervisor and also co-writer, left the job years prior to it was launched.

In the days considering that the launch of The Surge of Skywalker, that’s come to be a huge subject of conjecture amongst followers. What did the film appear like when Trevorrow, that ‘d been servicing the job for over 2 years, left in 2017? Usually that’s not something we would certainly figure out, yet a minimum of someone insurance claims they recognize.

That individual is filmmaker Robert Meyer Burnett. Burnett, that routed the Celebrity Trek-themed movie Capitalism, took place his YouTube program, Robservations, and also throughout 2 days outlined a whole manuscript he thinks was composed by Trevorrow and also Derek Connolly and also finished on December 16,2016 That manuscript was called Celebrity Wars Episode IX: Battle of the Fates.

io9 spoken to Disney to inquire about the manuscript, yet the workshop does not discuss reports or conjecture and also once more would not in this situation. We additionally connected to Lucasfilm particularly yet had actually not listened to back at the time of magazine, and also when spoken to, Trevorrow’s depiction had no remark. That suggests, already, nobody has actually validated or refuted the honesty of Burnett’s insurance claims. If that adjustments, we’ll upgrade this tale.

When It Comes To Burnett, he does not claim on his program where he obtained this manuscript, neither does he practically validate he in fact has a duplicate of the manuscript (although on the program, he’s plainly checking out from some type of display). What he does claim though is as complies with: “I don’t know if it’s real but I really believe that it is. I believe with all my heart it’s a real script because one, it’s a really well-written screenplay, and two, it’s too good to be unreal.” We talked to numerous resources with expertise of the scenario and also they either declare that the manuscript is actual or at least that Burnett is well-connected sufficient in Hollywood that he can have obtained it. Our good friends at the AV Club have additionally individually validated the authenticity.

If we pass those resources and also think it’s legitimate, the initial point to note is that day of December 16,2016 That’s most importantly vital due to the fact that it’s 11 days prior to the fatality of Carrie Fisher. Battle of the Fates was after that composed under the presumption Fisher can play a huge function in it, which she does. Her passing away, as we understand, was not simply an impact for followers all over, yet individuals making this film. It influenced the instructions of the tale significantly and also J.J. Abrams himself has actually claimed as a lot. December 2016 was additionally a year prior to the launch of The Last Jedi, so any type of concept of what followers would certainly think about the options because movie was still a lengthy method away. Every one of which is to claim, Battle of the Fates, in this type, was still fairly much from being what also Trevorrow can have placed on display.

Rey takes a brand-new course in Battle of the Fates.Photo: Disney

Every one of this initial emerged in a Reddit article where followers started going over Burnett’s insurance claims. Nevertheless, that article just took care of Monday’s episode of Burnett’s program. On Tuesday, he was back and also offered extra information, particularly on the finishing. If you intend to review an in-depth failure of the movie’s introduction and also 2nd act, you can do so on that particular Reddit article, or you can view the complete video clip. We’re simply mosting likely to speak about completion of the film as disclosed on Tuesday’s episode, which can be viewed right here.


In the supposed manuscript, Burnett claims Rey and also Kylo Ren satisfy on Mortis– the notorious world initially seen in the 3rd period of Duplicate Battles. It’s a nexus of the Living Pressure and also house to mystical beings run into by Ahsoka, Anakin, and also Obi-Wan that personified the light, dark, and also planetary aspects of the Pressure itself.

Mortis, Rey and also Ren think, is the beginning of the Living Pressure, a location where they’ll locate responses. As well as certainly, a massive lightsaber fight takes place, with Rey attempting to quit Kylo from entering into among the holy places there. Throughout the fight, Kylo slashes Rey throughout the face, she drops some staircases, and also he leaves her for dead. Kylo enters into the holy place just to locate … it’s vacant. There’s absolutely nothing there. Currently, Luke’s Pressure Ghost appears (yes, in 2016 Trevorrow and also Connolly were obviously functioning under the presumption that Luke passed away) and also provides a desperate initiative to transform him. Throughout his speech, Rey selects herself up yet has actually been blinded. Nonetheless, she places something over her eyes and also races back to challenge Kylo.

“Our masters were wrong,” Rey claimed. “I will not deny my anger. I will not reject my love. I am the darkness and I am the light.”

“You’re nothing. You’re no one,” Kylo reacts. Rey after that sparks her lightsaber and also claims “No one is no one” prior to performing at him, and also the fight proceeds. The line, according to Burnett, is a callback to previously in the movie when Rey is reviewing her family tree with Poe and also he discusses that everybody is that they intend to be. Nobody is nobody.

Rey, currently welcoming the light and also the dark, acquires an entire brand-new degree of power, slashes at Kylo’s hand, cuts his fingers, and also ruins his lightsaber. “There’s an unfathomable Living Force within her,” the manuscript claims. Nevertheless, previously in the film, Kylo had actually discovered the abnormal capability to swipe the Living Pressure from beings and also begins to do that to Rey. She can not manage it. Kylo is recovery and also he will win. Simply after that, he listens to the telephone call of his mom, asking him ahead house. Kylo gives up and also provides Rey her life significance back, yet at the same time starts to die himself. In his dying breath, he exposes her actual name: Rey Solana. (I believe that’s the punctuation, based upon hearing it. Additionally of note, Kylo recognizes this due to the fact that he’s the one that eliminated Rey’s moms and dads in this variation. He made use of to eliminate Force-sensitive youngsters for Snoke, that is additionally not in this manuscript, that makes feeling offered The Last Jedi, and also had actually located Rey years back. She left. Her moms and dads really did not.)

Kylo obtains retrieved, yet not as much, in Battle of the Fates.Photo: Disney

So Kylo is dead, Rey lives, yet simply hardly. She after that rises to a greater aircraft of presence and also comes across the Pressure Ghosts of Obi-Wan, Yoda, and also Luke. “Taught us much you have,” Yoda claims to Rey. Rey is puzzled. “Succeeded where we have failed. Narrow was our point of view,” he claims. “You chose to embrace the dark side and the light. To find the balance within,” claims Luke. “Co-exist they must,” claims Yoda. “As such feelings do in all of us.”

In an extremely Harry Potter-esque minute, Rey is after that confronted with a selection: Remain in this location and also gain knowledge, or return to the globe of the living, which will certainly be rough, yet she’ll live. As she considers it Obi-Wan leaves her with one last idea, “You are a Jedi, Rey Solana. But you will not be the last.” This entire summary is from concerning 1: 35 mins right into Burnett’s program with concerning 1: 44.

At The Same Time, as this is occurring, the large fight in between the Resistance and also the First Order is occurring on and also around Coruscant. Throughout the battle, R2-D2 is extremely harmed yet Chewbacca places the components on his back and also remains to combat. After the Rey and also Pressure Ghosts scene, the movie reduces to Coruscant post-victory. Chewbacca, Leia, C-3PO, and also others are placing R2 back with each other and also recollecting. The last item of the problem is to re-install his memory financial institution which Leia herself does, in a present similar to A Brand-new Hope. When she does, R2 ’ s memory begins to rebuild itself and also, as that’s occurring, every one of those memories begin predicting themselves. Sixty years of battle all from R2 ’ s viewpoint. Which generally winds up being a nine-episode Celebrity Battles highlight reel, something Trevorrow had actually meant back in 2016.

From there, the last scene of the movie happened on an earth called Modesta (possibly a wink to the birth place of George Lucas, Modesto, The Golden State). Finn exists with a number of youngsters and also Rey gets here, prepared to educate the future generation of Jedi. Roll credit ratings.

You were constantly mosting likely to win, Rey.Photo: Disney

2 various other enjoyable sidebars from completion of the movie. The First Order sheds, partly, due to the fact that its head office on Coruscant is a gigantic ship. Throughout the fight Rose Tico (that has a much majority in this variation of Episode IX) re-wires their hyperdrive to make sure that when the head office attempts to leave, it winds up collapsing right into an earth. Additionally, prior to that, Hux additionally has a fantastic fatality scene. Evidently a running joke in the manuscript is that he maintains attempting to utilize the Pressure to take on Kylo. When he understands the First Order is completed, he enters into his chambers and also we figure out he’s a secret Jedi geek and also has actually been gathering lightsabers. He lights one up and also utilizes it to pass away by self-destruction.

There’s so, a lot extra as well from earlier in the film– and also, once more, if you’re interested, I prompt you to go and also pay attention to both of Burnett’s programs. They’re lengthy and also a little dragged out yet over both video clips he discusses a lot even more of what this film could have been. As well as they might be the closest point we ever before reach their awareness.

Once Again, that’s if this is manuscript is actual. Would certainly seeing what we defined right here have been amazing? Yes. Much better than what we obtained? For some, maybe. Inevitably it would certainly’ve boiled down to implementation, and also there’s no warranty it would certainly have played out on display as it carries out in your head checking out these summaries. There’s additionally no sign, whatsoever, that this manuscript is widely “better” than what we obtained. It’s simply … various. As well as, in the long run, none of this issues. This is not the manuscript that was made; if it holds true, it’s an enjoyable item of facts which’s all that it is. She’s not Rey Solana. She’s Rey Skywalker, an offspring of Sheev Palpatine. As well as enjoy it or dislike it, that’s what it is.

If anything, Burnett’s evaluation of Battle of the Fates is a testimony to the amazing ability and also initiative the group at Lucasfilm have creating these films in addition to a possible home window right into the procedure. If this manuscript is actual, it’s evidence that there was greater than a little interaction taking place throughout the growth of all 3 films. This manuscript recognizes Luke was dead. It recognizes Snoke was dead. As well as the bones of it– Kylo’s look for power from a greater being, a message rejoining the Resistance, Pressure recovery– are what J.J. Abrams and also Chris Terrio made use of to make their film, which is why Trevorrow and also Connolly obtained tale credit rating.

The Surge of Skywalker is a development of these concepts, not a reset.


For even more, see to it you’re following us on our Instagram @io9dotcom.